Our family has been gluten-and casein-free for about four months. We made the decision to try the diet based on our research about the apparent connection between the digestive system and various psychological and neurological conditions, including autism.
Like most of the interventions we’ve tried, I have some very positive things to say about GF/CF, but nothing conclusive. What I can say about the diet is this – as part of a broad group of interventions, it’s been great.
A couple unexpected surprises from this diet:
- My wife and I feel great on this diet. We never feel bloated or gassy after a meal and we’ve lost a lot of weight. My wife has also come to realize that she is very sensitive to dairy and refined sugars. She never would have known this if we hadn’t tried the diet.
- Much to our surprise, our then 18-month old son (neurotypical) became much healthier and heavier after we went GF/CF. I don’t think most doctors would recommend going off dairy, but it’s been great for our baby. (He is also breast fed though).
Anyway, our four-year old son had been suffering from chronic constipation for over a year. He would hold the poop for 3-5 days and then, well…you can imagine the pain. As any parent in this situation knows, the constipation is a self-reinforcing cycle: it builds on itself as the child increasingly associates pain with pooping. By last May, we we’re really getting worried. The constipation was getting worse and our attempts to address it were mostly ineffective.
We initially tried to resolve the issue by adding fiber to his diet, but he refused to eat most of what we served. The best we could do was to force cooked prunes down him at every meal, which was about the only fiber-containing food he liked. We had to be vigilant to have any effect at all.
On the advice of doctors, we tried three different interventions over a period of several months. First, our pediatrician recommended Benefiber, a powdered supplement that mixes with food or drink. This did not help. Next they told us to use MiraLax, which was a complete disaster. Our son was doubled over in pain for about two weeks. In spite of the pain, the pediatrician insisted that we keep him on this stuff. Needless to say, we ignored their advice.
Instead, we went to a Pediatric GI specialist. She told us to get more fiber into our son’s diet (wow, thanks) and put him on Enulose. Neither of these strategies worked. That was when realized that our son needed something conventional medicine could not provide.
First, we went to an all-organic diet, hoping that healthier, less processed foods would make a difference. This decision was partly influenced by Marion Nestle’s amazing book What To Eat. A real eye-opener if you haven’t read it.
Well, my wife and I certainly felt better on the organic diet, and our son’s behavior seemed to level out a bit. (Although, as I mentioned in an earlier post, this may have been due to the fact that school ended about that same time.) Unfortunately, the constipation did not improve much.
I think it was late September when, after reading Healing the New Childhood Epidemics by Kenneth Bock, and Gut and Psychology Syndrome by Natasha Campbell-McBride, we decided to take the GF/CF plunge. I should also mention Children with Starving Brains, by Jacqueline McCandless, which, I believe was a groundbreaking book in the area of biomedical interventions for autism.
Since going GF/CF, our son’s constipation has improved slowly and steadily. First he started going every three to four days. After a month on the diet, it was more like every two to three days, then every other day. Finally, after three months on the diet, he was going almost every day.
In addition to the dietary intervention, my son needed a lot of coaching and encouraging from us to get him past his fear during this time. We had to keep reminding him that pooping more often would keep the poop small and less painful. We also had to find ways to introduce more fiber into his diet, which took some creativity. We still catch him holding the poop sometimes, and we have to tell him to go to the bathroom. But to go from pooping every five days to almost every day is just amazing.
Also, we’ve had a few setbacks. For example, when the weather got cold and dry, the constipation returned for a few days. At that point, we introduced a mega-fiber cookie, which we eat almost every day. We also do a mega-fiber pancake on weekends, which is a big hit. I’ll share both of those recipes soon.
As you probably already know, it can be difficult to assess the effectiveness of any single autism treatment since we often have multiple interventions running simultaneously, and because young children are developing and changing all the time.
In the case of my son’s constipation, however, I really feel strongly that GF/CF was crucial to his becoming regular.
I think, ultimately, the formula that worked for us was as follows:
- keeping him off gluten and dairy
- increasing his fiber intake
- dramatically reducing his intake of refined sugars and processed foods
- coaching him and encouraging him to push out the poop even when he was afraid
I have talked to some parents who have found the GF/CF diet totally ineffective. I don’t know if that’s because the diet wasn’t right for their child, or if they didnt’ stick to it strictly enough. It is not an easy thing to implement. I have also heard widely varying opinions on how long you have to stay with the diet to know whether or not it’s working. Some people say you’ll know almost immediately, others say you have to give it three months and still others say six-eight months.
I also understand that there are some kids who do better on the Specific Carbohydrate Diet or Sara’s no-Lutein diet. I’m surprised at how little information exists on the web about those diets. In any case, it’s unfortunate that there’s no intervention that works for everyone. We all have to feel our way around this dark room until we find a light switch.
In our case, GF/CF has been great, not just for my son, but for the whole family.